Arbitrage Blog

Read the latest blog post!


Life After the Holiday High

Written by Arbitrage2026-01-09 00:00:00

Arbitrage Blog Image

During the holidays, social calendars fill up, routines loosen, music and lights follow you into every store, and even ordinary errands carry a faint sense of the season. Then, almost overnight, everything collapses back into normal life. That emotional drop, often called the post-holiday blues, can feel confusing because it is like psychological whiplash: a sudden reduction in novelty, social connection, and anticipation, paired with a quick return to obligations, darker days, and the lingering effects of disrupted sleep, travel, alcohol, and spending. The National Association of Mental Illness (NAMI) reported that people often minimize what they are feeling: "It's just January," "I'm being dramatic," or "I should be fine" are common phrases people repeat to themselves. But the brain does not respond to the calendar; it responds to cumulative stress, unmet expectations, isolation, and fatigue.

Many people spend weeks planning for holiday events that are supposed to be meaningful, such as family gatherings, traditions, religious observances, reunions, and time off from work. When reality falls short of the ideal, that disappointment can sharpen into sadness. Debbie Fuehrer, a clinical counselor at Mayo Clinic, described that when holiday expectations clash with real life, the mismatch can feed a depressed mood. The holiday season can create "performance pressure" (Be joyful! Be social! Be grateful!) at a time some people already feel lonely or raw. Cleveland Clinic psychologist Dr. Dawn Potter noted how the holidays tend to spotlight togetherness, which can intensify the sense of being on the outside looking in - whether you live far from family, are single, recently moved, or feel disconnected even in a crowd. For anyone carrying grief, the "after" can sometimes feel worse than the "during." The planning and bustle of the holiday season can temporarily distract you, but once the noise fades, the absence becomes louder.


Biology and environment also play a role. Reduced daylight can sap energy and worsen mood for some people, especially those vulnerable to seasonal patterns. Cleveland Clinic psychologist Dr. Kia-Rai Prewitt explains how the lack of light can change daily experience: "It's dark when you get up. It's dark when you leave work. So you have less sunlight, and that sunlight really does give you a lot of energy." Add in holiday disruptions like late nights, travel, and irregular meals and your body may be trying to stabilize right when your schedule demands you snap back into productivity.


So what can help? First, treat the post-holiday blues as a transition, not a personal failure. Fuehrer emphasized shifting away from the perfection narrative and back toward stabilizers such as connection, attention, and small meaning. That does not mean forcing positivity; it means deliberately reintroducing the ingredients that quietly support mood (consistent sleep, movement, nourishment, and human contact) since holiday life often knocks those out of alignment.


Second, rebuild connections on purpose. The abrupt drop in social contact after the highly social season can feel like social withdrawal. Dr. Potter recommends reaching out to someone you have been meaning to connect with and making time together, ideally in person, but even a video call can help. Mood often improves not through one grand solution, but through repeated, low-friction moments of belonging.


Third, get serious about light and routine. If darker days correlate with your slump, prioritize morning daylight when possible, and consider discussing light therapy with a clinician if symptoms are recurrent and seasonal. Cleveland Clinic reported that light therapy lamps designed to simulate sunlight could boost a person's mood. Pair that with a steady wake time, regular meals, and gentle exercise - all of which are good for nervous system regulation.

Fourth, lower the bar on what January is supposed to feel like. Many people try to "fix" the blues by demanding immediate motivation - new goals, hard resets, perfect habits - and then feel worse when they cannot deliver. A more effective approach is to set expectations that fit the reality that January is often a recovery month.


The post-holiday blues are often the predictable result of high expectations, social intensity, disrupted routines, winter darkness, and the abrupt return to "regular life." If you respond with compassion and structure (light, sleep, movement, connection, and realistic expectations) you give your brain the conditions it needs to climb out of the dip. And if you cannot do it on your own, that is not a sign you failed the season; it is a sign you deserve support.

Like this article? Share it with a friend!