Arbitrage Blog

Read the latest blog post!


Trade War Backfire: US Assets Losing Global Appeal Fast

Written by Arbitrage2025-04-16 00:00:00

Arbitrage Blog Image

Investors Hit the Panic Button Over the past two weeks, the financial markets have felt like a rollercoaster gone off the rails. Tariffs between the US and China, historically high volatility, dropping equities - the market's drama rivals any Netflix series. Yet this time, investors reacted differently. Usually, when panic hits, everyone flees to the safety of US dollars and bonds. But in an unusual twist, both the dollar and US Treasuries plunged alongside stocks. Is this a sign that the US might be losing its position as the go-to safe haven? Let's dive deeper.

The Tariff Catalyst: China Strikes Back

Things took a sharp turn when China announced they'd raise tariffs on all US goods from 84% to a staggering 125%, effective April 12th. In an unprecedented move, Chinese officials dismissed the Trump administration's tariffs as a "joke," suggesting the US had become a less relevant trading partner. China's aggressive stance is about more than tariffs. There is speculation they're strategically selling US Treasuries to apply economic pressure and force the US to reconsider its tariff stance. This strategic maneuver has added significant stress to the Treasury market, contributing to recent volatility.


Bond Market Breakdown: Investors Abandon US Treasuries

What makes the recent turmoil truly unusual is what's happening in the bond market. Typically, when stocks crash, investors rush into bonds as a safe harbor. Instead, we've witnessed one of the largest weekly increases in bond yields in decades, with the 10-year yield reaching 4.49%. (Quick reminder: bond yields rise when bond prices fall.) There are a couple of reasons for this phenomenon. First, foreign investors - particularly from China and Japan - are selling their Treasury holdings. Second, many hedge funds running highly leveraged "basis trade" strategies were forced into panic-selling to meet margin calls. These hedge funds borrow money to exploit tiny differences between bond futures and actual bond prices. When markets move rapidly against them, they need to sell fast, amplifying the volatility and further pushing down bond prices.


Dollar Dethroned: Investors Lose Faith in USD

Historically, tariff escalations and geopolitical tensions push the US dollar higher, given its status as a global reserve currency. But this time, the exact opposite happened: the greenback dropped more than 3% against global currencies - its worst week since 2022. Meanwhile, alternative currencies, such as the euro and Swiss franc, surged. The euro saw its strongest performance in three years, and the Swiss franc reached a 10-year high. Minneapolis Federal Reserve President Neel Kashkari described this unusual shift clearly: investors worldwide might be reconsidering whether the United States remains the safest place to invest.


Gold Rush: A Clear Sign of Investor Fear

Amidst all this chaos, gold is shining brighter than ever. Initially, gold prices dropped briefly as panic set in, but quickly bounced back, hitting record highs. This rally is a clear indicator of fear in global markets. Investors are actively seeking protection, and gold, commodities, and other real assets have emerged as attractive alternatives to bonds and cash.


Foreign Exodus and Basis Trade Blow-up: A Double Whammy for Treasuries

China's aggressive tariff stance and selling of US Treasuries have added significant pressure on US bond prices. Some reports suggest they are quietly liquidating holdings through European entities, repeating a strategy they famously employed during the 2015 yuan devaluation crisis. Adding to the mix, rumors suggest Japan - another major foreign holder - is also reducing Treasury exposure. With the two largest foreign holders stepping back, the bond market faces substantial selling pressure. But there is also another force at play: the unraveling of the "basis trade." Hedge funds, employing leveraged trading strategies between bond futures and cash bonds, got squeezed by rising yields and falling bond prices. Many faced margin calls (forced selling to raise cash to cover their losses) which further intensified the sell-off. Together, foreign selling and basis-trade unwinding are creating a feedback loop of volatility, driving yields higher, bond prices lower, and spooking investors even more.


Impending Crisis: US Bond Market at a Crossroads

Looking ahead, there's an even bigger concern. The US Treasury needs to issue around $9 trillion of new bonds in the third quarter of 2025. If buyers remain hesitant, yields will have to rise even more to attract investment. High yields might sound good to investors initially, but they mean higher borrowing costs for businesses and consumers, - slowing economic growth, making mortgages and car loans more expensive, and potentially pushing the economy into recession. Remember, the bond market is significantly larger than the stock market - about $47 trillion for US bonds alone. For equity markets to stabilize and thrive again, bond markets must stabilize first. Without confidence returning to bonds, stocks and broader financial markets will continue experiencing intense volatility.


Can the US Restore Global Confidence?

The recent chaos clearly indicates that the US may no longer enjoy the same global appeal it once had. Tariffs designed to bolster US positions may have backfired spectacularly, causing foreign and domestic investors alike to reconsider their investment strategies. The US now faces a critical moment: restoring stability and credibility to its bond market. How quickly and effectively the market heals will determine if investors regain trust in US assets. Until then, brace yourself: market volatility is likely to continue.

Like this article? Share it with a friend!